Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)
No. 4, 2026
How Obligatory Is Fact-Based Obligation—A Discussion with Professor Chen Bo
(Abstract)
Bai Tongdong
The sharp distinction between “is” and “ought,” or between fact and value, is often traced to David Hume. The rejection of this distinction, however, has become a common view in contemporary philosophy. As can be seen in A Treatise of Human Nature, this distinction was not Hume’s central concern, and he also acknowledged the indirect role that facts may play in the formation of norms. Rather, his primary interest lay in the claim that moral sentiment, rather than reason, provides the motivating force behind behavior—a theme that continues to attract attention in contemporary philosophical debate. Amid skepticism about the absolute objectivity of facts, Professor Chen Bo attempts to ground the necessity of moral norms through naturalistic evolutionism within the framework of hypothetical imperatives. Although this approach has made some progress in analytic philosophy, such interpretations are often difficult to verify, and the biological necessities of survival of living entities do not necessarily give rise to normative necessity. When facts are theory-laden, natural science appears to exhibit some degree of necessity and unity, but this is largely the result of unified paradigms constructed by the scientific community.
