Hierarchical Relationship in Criminal Law Governance
05-21-2026

Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)

No. 4, 2026

 

Hierarchical Relationship in Criminal Law Governance

(Abstract)

 

Shi Jinghai

 

The hierarchical relationship in criminal law governance is formed in the process of criminal law’s participation in modern national governance. It reflects a progressive internal logic relation grounded in the coherence of criminal law’s internal norms, linked through the bilateral relationship of responsibility coordination between criminal law and prepositioning laws, supported by normative unity between criminal law and the entire legal system, and oriented toward diversified collaboration between criminal law and national governance. Its jurisprudential foundations lie in the unity of subjectivity and objectivity, the principle of legal order unity, the systematic scientific methodology, and the criminal policy of tempering justice with mercy. Currently, deep-seated contradictions encountered in criminal law governance—such as imbalances in misdemeanor governance and disjunctions between criminal, administrative, and civil law—mostly stem from oversimplified operational approaches, instrumentalized conceptualizations of this hierarchical relationship, and the limited adaptability between traditional criminal law interpretive mechanisms and the hierarchical relationship. At the legislative level, hierarchically coordinated normative systems should be established, while at the judicial level, a thinking of hierarchical coordination should be fostered. Such efforts would help restore the proper role of the hierarchical relationship of criminal law governance, provide systematic solutions to crime governance dilemmas, and lay the groundwork for the full implementation of the criminal policy of tempering justice with mercy and serving the modernization of national governance.