The Concept of “Unity” in Modern German History
06-01-2026

Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)

No. 5, 2026

 

The Concept of “Unity” in Modern German History

(Abstract)

 

Meng Zhongjie

 

The distinction made by 19th-century-German statesmen between “Einheit” (unity) and “Einigkeit” (agreement) reveals the inherent tension in the path toward modern German unification. “Einigkeit” refers to independent sovereignty coupled with coordinated action, representing the traditional model of the Holy Roman Empire. “Einheit,” by contrast, denotes the construction of a centralized nation-state derived from the pursuits of modernity in the Enlightenment thought. Throughout the 19th century, the concept of “Einheit”underwent multiple transformations in the political sphere: although proposals for a form of a “confederal unification” emerged after the Napoleonic Wars, the German Confederation established in 1815 in fact returned to a conservative paradigm of “Einigkeit;” the 1848 Revolution attempted to combine “Einheit” with liberalism but ended in failure; ultimately, the state of Prussia established a form of “Einheit” that excluded Austria through military force, while also sowing the seeds for the latent “German Question.” Thus, the evolution of the concept of “Einheit” in modern Germany was not a linear succession, but a process in which old and new concepts competed and coexisted within specific historical contexts. This process not only validates several features of the modern transformation of concepts, but also reveals the mutual definition of the two concepts mentioned above and the temporal overlapping of “historical institutions.” Unlike the continuity and peacefulness of Chinese civilization with unity in diversity, German “Einheit” involves a certain degree of rupture and displays an aggressive mindset of hegemony.