Reflection and Reconstruction of China’s Criminal Adjudication Theory
06-01-2026

Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)

No. 5, 2026

 

Reflection and Reconstruction of China’s Criminal Adjudication Theory

(Abstract)

 

Bai Langtao

 

How to overcome the tendency toward mechanical adjudication inherent in legal positivism is a major research issue in criminal adjudication theory. To this end, a structured philosophy of adjudication should be established. The relationship between “fact-finding” and “legal application” should shift from a dualistic relationship to a structured one. Interpretive theory, meanwhile, should shift from an epistemology based on a “subject-object dichotomy” to an ontology of “subject-object interweaving.” In terms of fact-finding, facts proven by civil or administrative evidence shall not be directly adopted as the facts in criminal cases. Factual induction must shift from a single perspective to a multi-faceted one. With respect to argumentation methods, the first round derivation of mixed hypothetical syllogism possesses only procedural value, whereas the second round derivation of categorical syllogism carries the value of reasoning in establishing the conformity of constitutive elements. The reasoning sequence follows the steps of “preliminary assessment→hypothesis→analogy→reductio ad absurdum→induction→deduction.” Moreover, a contrario reasoning is inadmissible when applied to the sufficient conditions for legal effects. In hard cases involving criminal-civil intersections or criminal-administrative coordination, functional judgments take precedence over relational judgments. The specific relationship should be determined on the basis of its distinctive function. The reconstruction outlined above—from adjudicative philosophy to methodology—facilitates the proper resolution of such hard cases.