Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)
No. 6, 2026
Characters, Cities, and Bronzes: Chinese Civilization from the Perspective of the Three Elements
(Abstract)
Yuan Guangkuo
Feng Shi has recently offered a dialectical critique of the criteria that define civilization in terms of such material elements as characters, cities, and bronzes. He argues that the traditional theory of the “three elements” reduces civilization to a material process of technological progress and social complexity, while neglecting its spiritual core and value pursuits. He proposes a theoretical system of civilization that takes morality as the foundation of becoming fully human, knowledge as the foundation of self-cultivation, and ritual as the foundation of governance, and on this basis traces the origins of Chinese civilization back 8,000 years. Certain aspects of this theory remain open to discussion. New archaeological discoveries continue to emerge, providing crucial materials for reassessing the criteria of civilization, such as brass artifacts dating back more than 6,000 years unearthed at Jiangzhai in Lintong, incised signs dating back 8,000 years discovered at Jiahu in Wuyang that bear connections to the Yinxu oracle-bone inscriptions, and city walls dating back 5,800 years found at Qingjinggou in Xingyang. These findings suggest that, even if characters, cities, and bronzes are retained as the criteria for defining civilization, the origins of Chinese civilization can still be traced back to a very early period.
