A Generative Theory of Argumentation Oriented toward the Lifeworld
09-08-2026

Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)

No. 6, 2026

 

A Generative Theory of Argumentation Oriented toward the Lifeworld

(Abstract)

 

Ju Shier

 

By viewing argumentation as a form of social interaction that occurs within the lifeworld, and examining argumentation theory from the perspective of arguers, it can be found that argumentation theory is often constrained by its methodological stance, making it difficult to capture the characteristics inherent in lifeworld argumentation, such as cultural diversity, individuality, dynamism, and generativity. In response, this study returns to the practical context of the lifeworld. Guided by the three principles of argumentation research—personalization, the emic-etic perspective, and dynamism—it proposes the concept of generalized argumentation capable of accommodating diverse argumentative practices across different cultures and domains, as well as their interactions among them. It further clarifies the generative processes of argumentative actions and argumentative sequences, and constructs a generative theory of argumentation oriented toward the lifeworld—Generalized Argumentation Theory. This theory can not only address problems of argumentation in the lifeworld, but also help explore possible solutions to current bottlenecks in large language models, providing a theoretical foundation for building a cross-cultural, cross-domain platform for argumentation.