Further Reflections on Causality and Consciousness—A Discussion with Wu Xiaoan
10-29-2026

Social Sciences in China (Chinese Edition)

No. 8, 2026

 

Further Reflections on Causality and Consciousness—A Discussion with Wu Xiaoan

(Abstract)

 

Zhang Jiji

 

In “Machine Consciousness and the Causal Self-Model,” Wu Xiaoan proposes that without a causal self-model, there can be no genuine machine consciousness. This is a bold proposal, but several aspects of its specific claims and arguments warrant discussion. Regarding the claim that a causal self-model is necessary for machine consciousness, both principal steps in the argument remain open to further discussion. First, constructing a causal self-model is not the only way to acquire the capacity for causal reasoning about oneself. Second, the capacities for causal reasoning and counterfactual thinking are not necessary conditions for high-level states of consciousness; they may instead be conditions only for certain specific contents of consciousness. In addition, the article’s claim to “integrate” mainstream theories of consciousness risks conflating causal structure at the ontological level with causal representation at the epistemological level. More promising approaches are also available for incorporating the self into structural causal models. There is no reason to assume a close connection between causal approaches to artificial intelligence and machine consciousness; the former neither take, nor should they take, the latter as their aim.